Showing posts with label Illeris. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Illeris. Show all posts

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Why I Hate "Program Planning" (Part 3)

When Knud Illeris wrote about education’s “sorting function” (Illeris, 2007, p. 237), he was primarily concerned with role that education plays in the replication of social inequity from one generation to the next; but, when I read the phrase, I thought of another reason why I don’t like the phrase “program planning.”

Why I *heart* Illeris (2007)

Illeris, K. (2007). How we learn: Learning and non-learning in school and beyond (M. Malone, Trans.). London and New York: Routledge.

Introductory Review
I first encountered this book in a class on Adult Learning.  I loved it.  Most of my colleagues did not.  As with the writings of many European intellectuals, Illeris is not an easy read.  Phraseology and sentence structures will feel foreign to most American readers, and it is sometimes difficult to identify the common thread that ties the various sections of a chapter together, especially at the beginning of a chapter.  However, readers who stick with Illeris will find that seemingly disparate thoughts come together in creative and convention-challenging ways. 

Notes on Illeris (2007) Chapter 12: Learning in Different Learning Spaces

Illeris, K. (2007). How we learn: Learning and non-learning in school and beyond (M. Malone, Trans.). London and New York: Routledge.

Chapter 12: Learning in different learning spaces (pp 214-233)

Before you begin reading these notes on Chapter 12 , you may want to read my overview/review of the entire book.  Notes for Chapter 13 can be found here.

Key Points
  1. Types of Learning Spaces
    1. Everyday Learning
      1. Illeris prefers this term over “informal learning” and “non-formal learning” because:
        1. There is really no distinction between informal and non-formal learning forms
        2. It makes clear “unintended, yet omnipresent” nature of this type of learning (p. 216)
        3. It implies the importance of context.
    2. Schools/Educational Contexts

Notes on Illeris (2007) Chapter 13: Learning, Education, and Society

Illeris, K. (2007). How we learn: Learning and non-learning in school and beyond (M. Malone, Trans.). London and New York: Routledge.

Chapter 13: Learning, education, and society (pp 234-252)

Before you begin reading these notes on Chapter 13 , you may want to read my overview/review of the entire book.  Notes from Chapter 12 can be found here.

Key Points
  1. Assumptions/Misunderstandings about Learning/Education that are prevalent in society
    1. Even those who know they are these conceptions are false tend to embrace them because they are that engrained in the culture.
    2. “The key function of the misunderstandings has precisely been to veil the adaptation, disciplining and selection that suited the old industrial society” (p. 238)

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Why I Hate "Program Planning" (Part 1)

I strongly dislike the term “program planning.” Why I have such a strong, negative reaction toward the phrase is not entirely clear, however. Nearly six months of reflection on the matter has failed to produced a coherent argument. Unconnected mental-emotional snippets clog my brain, so today I am trying something new: blogging my thoughts. This post, therefore, represents the first in what is likely to become a lengthy series. As this series progresses, please feel free to comment, offering advice, insight, and (gentle) critique. Perhaps together we can figure out why I hate “program planning.”

In a chapter on learning spaces, Knud Illeris (2007) describes how divided and disjointed modern life has become. Learning that takes place in one realm of life—say, the school—does not